In five weeks, the United States will have a new “First Lady” who replaces a model—sometimes in the nude—who gained entrance to the country, just like her parents, from her husband’s manipulations. Dr. Jill Biden, an educator at a community college, has a bachelor’s degree, two master’s degrees, and a doctor of education. While earning three of these degrees, she was pregnant, cared for three children, taught (including adolescents at a psychiatric hospital), and campaigned for her as vice-president and president.
In her “spare time,” Dr. Biden founded the Biden Health Initiative non-profit organization and co-founded the Book Buddies program for low-income families, Biden Foundation, and Joining Forces with Michelle Obama. She is also active in Delaware Boots on the Ground, supporting military families.
Yet Joseph Epstein chose to criticize in the conservative Wall Street Journal, supposedly about finance, about Dr. Biden’s request to use her title instead of “Mrs.” Calling her “kiddo,” Epstein slammed the title as “fraudulent” and “comical.” To Epstein, “Dr.” is used only for medical doctors—those who have “delivered a child.” Technically, Dr. Biden has “delivered a child.” He also denigrated her dissertation, “Student Retention at the Community College Level: Meeting Students’ Needs,” with the descriptor “unpromising.”
Bragging about not asking his students to call him “Dr.” when he was a “lecturer” at Northwestern University, he skipped over his lack of a degree beyond his baccalaureate except an “honorary” doctorate at Adelphi University, not an earned degree. People in the know also commented that Epstein didn’t prevent his students from calling him Dr. Epstein. He also used his attack on Dr. Biden to attack honorary doctorates and higher education. He said that teachers, the same thing he did, were paid handsomely for working only six months a year. He also objected to Black women receiving honorary doctorates.
Phyllis Zagano, Ph.D. and senior research associate-in-residence at Hofstra University, has a few insights into Epstein in the National Catholic Reporter.
“The world is too connected, and life is too short, for people to keep harping on each other over an election that your husband won. There are other issues: global warming, unemployment, immigration. And, I know I don’t need to tell you, people dying by the minute from COVID-19. Even so, I hope you will address questions about education in the United States soon after you set up your Washington office.
“But, back to The Wall Street Journal and its essay writer, 83-year-old Joseph Epstein. For many years, Epstein taught writing and literature as a visiting lecturer at Northwestern University. Nearly concurrently, he edited the Phi Beta Kappa journal, The American Scholar. At Northwestern, he is said to have ignored and demeaned his female students.
“Writing in The Hudson Review, he memorably called women scholars ‘pit bulls’ and worse. Joyce Carol Oates wrote that his editorial reign was ‘an embarrassment.’”
Zagano added that WSJ’s op-ed editor, Paul A. Gigot, worsened the situation by defending Epstein’s piece. Instead Gigot claimed the outcry came from Biden’s transition team strategy instead of a protest against misogyny. She concludes by addressing Dr. Biden:
“I want you to know that there are many others of us out here who have been treated identically, although perhaps not so in print. Whether our doctorates are 40 years old or newly awarded on Zoom, we have been subject to sniping about our research, our teaching and our university service ever since we stepped into the classroom. We have been given the worst teaching days and times, and we have received some of the silliest classroom evaluations you can imagine. We have also suffered comments, foul jokes and even untoward advances from the senior male faculty members on whom our jobs depended. Sneering comments about using ‘Dr.’ are the least of it.”
Fox’s Tucker Carlson is making sure the discussion stays in the right-wing limelight. Wednesday, he referred to the soon-to-be First Lady as “poor illiterate Jill Biden” and her dissertation “our national shame.” To prove he wasn’t being sexist, Carlson ranted about Joe Biden’s stupidity. According to a rumor Carlson wants to run for president in 2024. (Carlson has a BA but failed to get into the CIA.)
Northwestern University, which employed Epstein in a non-tenured position until 2002, stated it “strongly disagrees with Mr Epstein’s misogynistic views.” The school has removed his name from its website.
With his former “high-level” position at a university, Epstein ignores the importance of community colleges where one-third of students in higher education attend. Dr. Biden wrote about the diversity and importance of these schools in her dissertation introduction:
“The community college classroom is unlike any other classroom in America. Diversity, rather than homogeneity, is the norm. In an average-sized class of twenty students at Delaware Tech, for example, most of the seats will be filled with young students who have just graduated from high school. The majority of these will be female. At least five seats will be filled with middle-aged men and women who have lost their jobs due to downsizing and/or outsourcing. One or two seats will be filled with students who have graduated from a GED program. Some seats will hold older women whose children have just entered college – now these women are taking the opportunity to earn college degrees themselves. Three quarters of the class will be Caucasian; one quarter of the class will be African American; one seat will hold a Latino; and the remaining seats will be filled with students of Asian descent or non-resident aliens. At least one quarter of the students will have children – most of them will be single mothers. Some will be the first in their families to attend college.”
Even Merriam-Webster, publishing definitions for almost two centuries, entered the Twitter fray:
“The word doctor comes from the Latin word for ‘teacher,’ itself from docēre, meaning ‘to teach.'”
On Twitter, Merriam-Webster has lots of company in commenting on Epstein’s piece. From Bernice King, the youngest daughter of civil rights leader Dr. Martin Luther King Jr:
“My father was a non-medical doctor. And his work benefited humanity greatly. Yours does, too.”
Chasten Buttigieg, a teacher and Pete Buttigieg’s husband, tweeted:
“The author could’ve used fewer words to just say ‘ya know in my day we didn’t have to respect women.’”
Buttigieg is using Epstein’s attacks to raise money for the community college foundation where Dr. Biden teaches.
Epstein, a Jewish man born in 1937 when Hitler was planning to exterminate all non-straight, non-Aryan people, doesn’t reserve his disdain for women: in a Harper Magazine essay published in 1970, he described gay people as “cursed” and “an affront to our rationality.” He wrote:
“If I had the power to do so, I would wish homosexuality off the face of the earth… nothing [my four sons] could ever do would make me sadder than if any of them were to become homosexual.”
The backlash concerned him about being called a “homophobe” because, according to Epstein, it’s a “stupid word.”
While Epstein has focused his attack on a woman, he had no complaints about Dr. Henry Kissinger. Epstein’s parting advice to Dr. Biden:
“Forget the small thrill of being Dr. Jill and settle for the larger thrill of living for the next four years in the best public housing in the world as First Lady Jill Biden.”
Epstein sees her glory in something her husband did and not her own accomplishments because she’s the “little woman.”
Former First Lady Michelle Obama, who has a Doctor of Law degree, described Dr. Biden: “a brilliant woman who has distinguished herself in her profession and with the life she lives every day, always seeking to lift others up, rather than tearing them.” Doug Emhoff, the Second Gentleman as of January 20, 2021, tweeted about Epstein’s article:
“Dr. Biden earned her degrees through hard work and pure grit. She is an inspiration to me, to her students, and to Americans across this country. This story would never have been written about a man.”
Hillary Clinton tweeted:
“Her name is Dr. Jill Biden. Get used to it.”
Epstein’s essay may be a boon to Dr. Jill Biden. People who read about it will hopefully know about her accomplishments—apart from being married to the President of the United States.
People could call the controversy a petty issue, but it partly explains why Dictator Donald Trump (DDT) got over 74 million votes—classism, sexism, anti-education, bullying, jealousy, ignorance, and pettiness. Like Dr. Biden, I have a BA, two M.A.s, and an Ed.D. I choose not to use the word “Dr.”—unless people look down on me because I don’t dress elegantly in my retirement on the Oregon coast and I’m a female. Since arriving in my small town home, I had a formal political debate with a man. He was called “Dr.” and I was referred to by my first name. When males consider women as equal, maybe the use of “Dr.” will no longer be an issue.
U.S. daily COVID-19 cases rise: 248,686 new infections; 3,538 deaths.