News about the mass shooting in Uvalde (TX) on May 24 keeps leaking out. Killed were 19 students under 11 years old in an elementary classroom with their two teachers while 19 law enforcement officers stayed in the hallway and heard shots inside the room. Another 17 people were injured, and the shooter was finally killed after 78 minutes while children kept calling 911 for help and parents begged to get inside to save their children.
Texas was supposedly investigating police mistakes, but the city police and the school district are no longer cooperating with any probe after a press conference on May 27 when DPS Director, Col. Steven McCraw, said delaying policy entry to save the children was “the wrong decision” and contrary to protocol. ISD Police Chief Pete Arredondo, who ordered law enforcement to wait over an hour, was sworn onto the Uvalde city council on May 31 despite the claim it would wait. He stopped cooperating with state investigators and has not responded to requests for information since Friday, according to the Texas Department of Public Safety. Police chief and school district spokesperson are not commenting about these events.
The police had tried to blame a teacher for blocking open a door and allowing the shooter to enter, but their accusation has now been proved wrong by a video showing that the woman slammed the door shut. It was supposed to automatically lock. She ran inside and called 911 but returned to shut the door when she heard someone yelling about the attacker and saw the shooter with a gun jump the fence.
On May 25, a federal judge in New York ruled that manufacturers can be held liable when “a manufacturer or seller of a [firearm] knowingly violated a State or Federal statute applicable to the sale or marketing of the product.” A New York law permits gun violence victims, their families, and the state of New York “to hold bad actors in the gun industry accountable for their role in fueling the epidemic of gun violence.” The industry has tried to claim the law “unconstitutional.” A 2005 law signed by George W. Bush gave the weapons industry almost complete immunity from charges by victims of their products, preventing them from the lawsuits controlling Big Tobacco.
On May 17, the day after his 18th birthday, the shooter bought two Daniel Defense DDMA V7 rifles, modeled after the military’s go-to rifle the M4 carbine. Each one sells for over $1,870. This rifle has become popular with mass shooters because it shoots a heavier round at much higher velocities. Greater momentum results in greater tissue damage in the body, guaranteeing death if a person is hit in the pelvic area or upper shoulder, unlike being shot by a handgun. The NRA raffled off the Daniel Defense DDMA V7 rifle as part of its conference festivities three days after the murders.
The popular manufacturer of AR-15 style assault rifles has a questionable history of advertising. Days before the shooting, the company posted a photograph of a toddler cradling one of its guns with the verse form Proverbs 22:6, “Train up a child in the way he should go, and when he is old, he will not depart from it.” The NFL refused a Daniel Defense Ad during the 2014 Super Bowl XLVIII. It focused on a man coming home to his wife and baby with this voiceover:
“I am responsible for their protection, and no one has the right to tell me how to defend them. So I’ve chosen the most effective tool for the job.”
Owner Marty Daniel turned the rejection from the NFL into free publicity. He targets younger customers with pop culture icons and video games as well as older people in the U.S. and gun control. On the day of the shooting, Daniel Defense tweeted, “Do you run a DDM4 V7? With a photo of the company’s branded ball cap and vest with the rifle in full view.
After the Uvalde killing, he echoed the GOP standard reaction—“our thoughts and our prayers.” Since then, he has kept a lower profile in not attending the NRA convention. In 2017, the shooter who killed 58 people at an outdoor music festival in Las Vegas had four Daniel Defense semi-automatic rifles. Daniel’s Facebook page used the “thoughts and prayers” message. He thinks God granted “the right to bear arms.”
Daniel has “hardened” since a mass shooter killed 26 people in the Sutherland Springs (TX) First Baptist Church, and he briefly backed a federal bill to strengthen the nation’s firearms background check. With a domestic violence record, that killer should not have been able to purchase firearms, but the charges weren’t logged into the right database. Congress corrected that problem. Daniel’s customers were furious, and he backed down. About mass shootings, Daniel said:
“The first thing you do is hope your gun wasn’t used. And if your gun was used, you would try to rationalize it. We did everything legal, right? What else could we have done?”
After mass shootings, the media make much of the firearm but almost nothing about the bullets. But bullets in the military-style weapons purchased in Texas with no license can produce so much damage that the dead children could be identified only through DNA. In his online messages, the shooter bragged about his expanding, hollow-point bullets, the most destructive form of ammunition thus far. Their use on the battlefield is a war crime, the Hague Convention bans them, and the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court bars their use. The 18-year-old teenager bought 375 of these rounds for his rampage. The U.S. has no federal law against stacking these bullets in a high-capacity magazine for weapons of war used by civilians in their mass killings.
Guns now kill more children than car accidents. More children die of gunfire than on-duty police officers and active military members. When the CDC began to examine gun violence in the 1990s as a public health issue, the NRA led opposition to strip the research of funding. By 2020, the rate of deaths from gun injuries was 25 percent higher than those in car crashes. Legislation has made cars safer while many states legislate greater danger from gun ownership. The U.S. has far more guns than industrialized European and Asian countries along with a homicide rate 49 times higher and a firearm suicide rate eight times higher. Assaults with firearms in states with the most guns were 6.8 times more common in 2015 than states with the least guns. Higher gun ownership equates to higher rates of homicide, and having a gun in the home doubles the chance of chance of being killed with a gun. In places where guns or gun dealers open for business, killings increase. When Missouri repealed its permit law, gun-related killings increased 25 percent.
Shootings of over 8 people doubled in frequency in the decade after 2010, according to University of Alabama criminologist Dr. Adam Lankford. They also worsened in number of fatalities and targeted elementary school children. Shootings aren’t random, and shooters learn from each other in contagion copycat effects. In over half the U.S. incidents, the shooter had more than one firearm, and many of them didn’t own any guns until the last year of their attack.
More research about gun ownership:
Last year, a poll showed people wanted to stop people with mental illnesses from purchasing guns by a majority of 87 percent to 12 percent.
The same poll showed people wanting background checks for private gun sales and sales at gun shows by 81 percent to 18 percent.
Even a majority, 64 percent to 36 percent, favor “banning high-capacity ammunition magazines that hold more than 10 rounds.”
In 2005, California had 9.5 firearms deaths per 100,000 people that year, Florida had 10 and Texas 11. California tightened its gun laws while Florida and Texas loosened them. With one of the ten lowest rates of gun deaths in the nation, California’s rate of gun deaths declined by 10 percent; rates in Texas and Florida climbed 28 percent and 37 percent respectively.
Chicago is often cited for its large number of gun-related homicides, but the vast majority of guns used in these crimes come from neighboring states having lax laws.
The states with America’s lowest rates of gun-related deaths all have strict gun laws; states allowing easy availability of guns have higher rates.
Banning assault weapons in 1994 reduced mass shootings killings by 43 percent; repealing it in 2004 shot it up by 239 percent.
In a move against a Texas law, the U.S. Supreme Court temporarily blocked Texas’ mandate preventing large social media platforms such as Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube from moderating any content. Justice Elena Kagan joined three conservative justices—Samuel Alito, Neil Gorsuch, and Clarence Thomas—in agreeing that posts promising kidnapping, murder, rape, etc. as well as disinformation about COVID, election rigging, ISIS proselytizing, and Russia pro-invasion of Ukraine propaganda should not be blocked. Neither the majority nor Kagan explained their rationale.
Fortunately, the DOJ is also investigating the tragic fiasco in Ulvade, Texas. State officers appear to be too incompetent to carry out the probe. This isn’t the end.